Judging three agencies’ work side by side changes what you notice
Reviewing portfolios one after another loses the thread. Here is how to judge a shortlist side by side instead, and what it surfaces that a solo review misses.
Reviewing portfolios one after another loses the thread. Here is how to judge a shortlist side by side instead, and what it surfaces that a solo review misses.
Unprompted over-explanation in a portfolio review is its own craft signal, separate from the work. Here is how to tell the two apart.
A portfolio page and a highlight reel are not a sample. Here is what a fair look at an agency’s craft actually requires before you form an opinion.
Craft and originality are separate axes. Here is how to check where a social concept actually came from before you credit the agency for it.
Highlight reels show peak weeks. The honest test of an agency’s floor is the ordinary quarter when nothing launched and nothing trended.
Agencies that call a repost a collaboration or a single post a campaign are telling you something before you see the actual creative.
A post can fail for two different reasons. Here is how to tell a craft problem from a strategy problem when you never saw the brief.
A feed that changed hands leaves a seam you can read. Here is how to use that seam to isolate one agency’s actual contribution.
Portfolios show the best three posts. The one they did not bother to hide tells you what the agency actually does by default.
One standout format on an account can hide a thin bench elsewhere. Here is how to read the gap between an agency’s best and worst format.